GOP Rep. Barton tells man to ‘shut up’ in testy town hall
Gabby Kaufman
A Texas congressman told a constituent to “shut up” in a heated
moment caught on video. Rep. Joe Barton, R-Texas, was
holding a town hall last weekend in the city of Frost, the Dallas Morning News reported, when a man
confronted him about his voting record pertaining to violence against women.
“Given your voting record opposing protecting women from violence,
will you make a commitment to us today — make a promise — that you will reach
out to Congresswoman Jackie Speier and work with her to see this bill
successfully through Congress?” the man asked, drawing applause from the crowd.
Speier, a Democrat, recently introduced a bill that would prohibit
military service members from sharing intimate photos without the subject’s
permission. The bill was introduced in response to the Marines United scandal, in which a private
Facebook group made up of Marines was being used to share nude photos of
servicewomen.
Referring to a previous bill he had voted against, Barton said, “I
voted against it because I think that’s a state issue, not a federal issue.”
In the video, some
in the crowd in the conservative state applaud Barton, while others jeer him.
“It’s violence
against women, that’s a national issue. That is an issue that impacts everyone,
everywhere — not only in this country, but everywhere,” one man says.
“It’s civil rights,” another adds.
The simplest comment is what set Barton off. A man calls out, “You
represent Texas first.”
“You,” Barton says, pointing to the man, who is not seen on camera,
“you, sir, shut up.”
Many in the crowd seem bewildered, and a man can be heard saying,
“What is that? You don’t tell anybody to shut up. You work for us!” as the
video ends.
The video spread
across the Web on Tuesday, becoming the latest in an ongoing series of viral
moments sparked by Republican House members’ town halls. In the aftermath of
Democrats’ wide-ranging 2016 losses, critical constituents have flooded many GOP town hall events.
A spokesman for Barton did not immediately respond to a request for
comment. In an appearance on MSNBC on Tuesday addressing the incident, Barton
skirted his volatile reaction to his constituent and instead reiterated his
state’s rights. “My opinion is that there are some issues that are totally
federal issues and there are some issues that the proper jurisdiction is at the
state level,” he said.
“Most laws with
domestic violence are state issues and handled by the state of Texas,” he
continued. “We had the Navarro County district attorney in the audience, and I
don’t believe you caught that on your — what you just showed, but I asked him
did he prosecute the domestic violence cases in Navarro County every year, and
the answer was, obviously, he did. So, the fact that somebody wants to make it
a federal issue — that’s one of the problems, in my opinion, that too many
times, we’re now looking to the federal government and making it a federal
issue.”
No comments:
Post a Comment